OpenClovis Product Documentation

Revision as of 05:49, 1 October 2010

csa203 Checkpointing

Objective

csa203 demonstrates how to use the Clovis Checkpoint service to provide basic failure recovery. csa203 builds on csa202.

What Will You Learn

• how to initialize the checkpoint client library,
• how to create a checkpoint and open a checkpoint,
• how to create a section in the checkpoint
• how to save data to the checkpoint section and read data from the checkpoint section.

The Code

The code can be found within the following directory

<project-area_dir>/eval/src/app/csa103Comp

ClCompAppInitialize()

        ...

        if ((rc = checkpoint_initialize()) != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: Failed [0x%x] to initialize checkpoint",
                    appname, rc);
            return rc;
        }
        if ((rc = checkpoint_read_seq(&seq)) != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: Failed [0x%x] to read checkpoint",
                    appname, rc);
            checkpoint_finalize();
            return rc;
        }
    #ifdef CL_INST
        if ((rc = clDataTapInit(DATA_TAP_DEFAULT_FLAGS, 103)) != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: Failed [0x%x] to initialize data tap",
                    appname, rc);
        }
    #endif

  

The above software in clCompAppMain.c is new to csa103. The call to checkpoint_initialize is pretty straightforward. This function discussed in detail later within this section. The call to checkpoint_read_seq is also pretty straightforward. It reads the current sequence value from the checkpoint (at this point it should be zero) and loads it into the variable: seq. It is important to note the call to checkpont_finalize if the call to checkpoint_read_seq does not return CL_OK. This call closes the checkpoint and cleanly finalizes the checkpoint library. We'll look more at checkpoint_read_seq and checkpoint_finalize later.

        /* Checkpoint new sequence number */
        rc = checkpoint_write_seq(seq);
        if (rc != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: ERROR: Checkpoint write failed. Exiting.", appname);
            break;
        }
  

The rest of the csa103's main loop is the same as the main loop in csa102, but the seven lines above are new. Here we write the new value of the checkpoint variable to the checkpoint section and print and error if this fails. We'll look closer at checkpoint_write_seq later.

    ClRcT
    clCompAppAMFCSISet(
        ClInvocationT       invocation,
        const ClNameT       *compName,
        ClAmsHAStateT       haState,
        ClAmsCSIDescriptorT csiDescriptor)
    {    
        /*
         * ---BEGIN_APPLICATION_CODE--- 
         */
        ClCharT     compname[100]={0};

        /*
         * ---END_APPLICATION_CODE---
         */

        /*
         * Print information about the CSI Set
         */
        strncpy(compname, compName->value, compName->length);

        clprintf (CL_LOG_SEV_INFO, "Component [%s] : PID [%d]. CSI Set Received", 
              compname, (int)mypid);

        clCompAppAMFPrintCSI(csiDescriptor, haState);
    
        /*
          Take appropriate action based on state
        */
    
        switch ( haState )
        {
            case CL_AMS_HA_STATE_ACTIVE:
            {
                /*
                  AMF has requested application to take the active HA state
                  for the CSI.
                */
    
                /*
                  ---BEGIN_APPLICATION_CODE---
                */
  

   
                clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO,"%s: Active state requested from state %d",
                        appname, ha_state);

                if (ha_state == SA_AMF_HA_STANDBY)
                {
                    /* Read checkpoint, make our replica the active replica */
                    clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO,"%s reading checkpoint", appname);
                    rc = checkpoint_read_seq(&seq);
                    clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO,"%s read checkpoint: seq = %u", appname, seq);
                }
                checkpoint_replica_activate();            
                ha_state = SA_AMF_HA_ACTIVE;


                /*
                 * ---END_APPLICATION_CODE---
                 */

                clCpmResponse(cpmHandle, invocation, CL_OK);
                break;
            }

            case CL_AMS_HA_STATE_STANDBY:
            {
                /*
                 * AMF has requested application to take the standby HA state 
                 * for this CSI.
                 */

                /*
                 * ---BEGIN_APPLICATION_CODE---
                 */

                 clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO," Standby state requested from state %d",ha_state);
            
                 ha_state = SA_AMF_HA_STANDBY;

                /*
                 * ---END_APPLICATION_CODE---
                 */

                clCpmResponse(cpmHandle, invocation, CL_OK);
                break;
        }

  

    
            case CL_AMS_HA_STATE_QUIESCED:
            {
                /*
                 * AMF has requested application to quiesce the CSI currently
                 * assigned the active or quiescing HA state. The application 
                 * must stop work associated with the CSI immediately.
                 */

                /*
                 * ---BEGIN_APPLICATION_CODE---
                 */

                clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO,"%s: QUIESCED", appname);
                ha_state = haState;

                /*
                 * ---END_APPLICATION_CODE---
                 */

                clCpmResponse(cpmHandle, invocation, CL_OK);
                break;
            }

            case CL_AMS_HA_STATE_QUIESCING:
            { 
                /*
                 * AMF has requested application to quiesce the CSI currently
                 * assigned the active HA state. The application must stop work
                 * associated with the CSI gracefully and not accept any new
                 * workloads while the work is being terminated.
                 */

                /*
                 * ---BEGIN_APPLICATION_CODE---
                 */

                clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO,"%s: QUIESCING", appname);
                ha_state = haState;

                /*
                 * ---END_APPLICATION_CODE---
                 */

                clCpmCSIQuiescingComplete(cpmHandle, invocation, CL_OK);
                break;
            }
  

            default:
            {
                break;
            }
        }
    
        return CL_OK;
    }
  

Now looking at csa103's implementation of clCompAppAMFCSISet, we see that rather than just a few cases, we handle several cases: QUIESCING, QUIESCED, ACTIVE, and STANDBY. In each state, the global variable ha_state to the new_state value that is passed in is set. This is similar to csa102, except that we add the feature that in the CL_AMS_HA_STATE_ACTIVE case if our previous state was CL_AMS_HA_STATE_STANDBY we read the sequence from the checkpoint so that the main loop will pick it up.

    static ClRcT
    checkpoint_initialize()
    {
        SaAisErrorT      rc = CL_OK;
        SaVersionT ckpt_version = {'B', 1, 1};
        SaNameT    ckpt_name = { strlen(CKPT_NAME), CKPT_NAME };
        ClUint32T  seq_no;
        SaCkptCheckpointCreationAttributesT create_atts = {
            .creationFlags     = SA_CKPT_WR_ACTIVE_REPLICA_WEAK |
                             SA_CKPT_CHECKPOINT_COLLOCATED,
            .checkpointSize    = sizeof(ClUint32T),
            .retentionDuration = (ClTimeT)10,
            .maxSections       = 2, // two sections 
            .maxSectionSize    = sizeof(ClUint32T),
            .maxSectionIdSize  = (ClSizeT)64

        
        };
        SaCkptSectionCreationAttributesT section_atts = {
        .sectionId = &ckpt_sid,
        .expirationTime = SA_TIME_END

        };
 
        clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO,"%s: checkpoint_initialize", appname);
        /* Initialize checkpointing service instance */
        rc = saCkptInitialize(&ckpt_svc_handle,	/* Checkpoint service handle */
						  NULL,			    /* Optional callbacks table */
						  &ckpt_version);   /* Required verison number */
        if (rc != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: ERROR: Failed to initialize checkpoint service",
                    appname);
            return rc;
        }
        clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO,"%s: Checkpoint service initialized (handle=0x%llx)",
           appname, ckpt_svc_handle);
  

Here is checkpoint_initialize. Here we initialize the ClNameT structure that holds the name of the checkpoint to be opened/created with the line: ClNameT ckpt_name = { strlen(CKPT_NAME), CKPT_NAME };. We then define a set of attributes to associate with the checkpoint when creating that checkpoint. The creationFlags includes CL_CKPT_WR_ACTIVE_REPLICA. This means that the checkpoint to be created will be asynchronous, or once active server updation is completed, the call returns to the application, all other replica updates happens parallel. CheckpointSize is set to the sizeof a 32 bit unsigned integer, which is the sequence number we print in the main loop. The retentionDuration is the time that the checkpoint service will keep the checkpoint in store after the last client has closed the checkpoint. MaxSections is 2 as this checkpoint will be used to store two sections. MaxSectionSize is the set to the sizeof a 32 bit unsigned integer, as application stores only unsigned integer. And maxSectionIdSize is 64 bytes.

We next use ClCkptSectionCreationAttributesT section_atts to define the creation attributes for the sole section of the checkpoint. The sectionId is just the name of the section along with the number of bytes in the name. The expirationTime is set to CL_TIME_END to imply that the section is never deleted automatically if the checkpoint itself still remains.

The call to clCkptInitialize has to be called before any other checkpoint functions. The ckpt_svc_handle is where the handle is returned. The handle must be passed to some future checkpoint api calls, namely the clCkptCheckpointOpen and clCkptFinalize calls. The callbacks table is passed as NULL which implies that our application doesn't provide any callbacks. Finally the ckpt_version identifies what version of the api this application is written to.

        //
        // Create the checkpoint for read and write.            

        rc = saCkptCheckpointOpen(ckpt_svc_handle,      // Service handle
                              &ckpt_name,         // Checkpoint name
                              &create_atts,       // Optional creation attr.
                              (SA_CKPT_CHECKPOINT_READ |
                               SA_CKPT_CHECKPOINT_WRITE |
                               SA_CKPT_CHECKPOINT_CREATE),
                              (SaTimeT)-1,        // No timeout
                              &ckpt_handle);      // Checkpoint handle

        if (rc != SA_AIS_OK)

        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: ERROR: Failed [0x%x] to open checkpoint",
                    appname, rc);
            (void)saCkptFinalize(ckpt_svc_handle);
            return rc;
        }
        clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO,"%s: Checkpoint opened (handle=0x%llx)", appname, ckpt_handle);
  

        /*
         * Try to create a section so that updates can operate by overwriting
         * the section over and over again.
         * If subsequent processes come through here, they will fail to create
         * the section.  That is OK, even though it will cause an error message
         * If the section create fails because the section is already there, then
         * read the sequence number
         */
        // Put data in network byte order
        seq_no = htonl(seq);

        // Creating the section
        checkpoint_replica_activate();
        rc = saCkptSectionCreate(ckpt_handle,           // Checkpoint handle
                             &section_atts,         // Section attributes
                             (SaUint8T*)&seq_no,    // Initial data
                             (SaSizeT)sizeof(seq_no)); // Size of data
        if (rc != SA_AIS_OK && (CL_GET_ERROR_CODE(rc) != SA_AIS_ERR_EXIST))
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: ERROR: Failed to create checkpoint section", appname);
            (void)saCkptCheckpointClose(ckpt_handle);
            (void)saCkptFinalize(ckpt_svc_handle);
            return rc;
        }
        else if (rc != SA_AIS_OK && (CL_GET_ERROR_CODE(rc) == SA_AIS_ERR_EXIST))
        {
            rc = checkpoint_read_seq(&seq);
            if (rc != CL_OK)
            {
                clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: ERROR: Failed [0x%x] to read checkpoint section",
                            appname, rc);
                (void)saCkptCheckpointClose(ckpt_handle);
                (void)saCkptFinalize(ckpt_svc_handle);
                return rc;
            }
        }
        else
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_INFO,"%s: Section created", appname);
        }

        return CL_OK;
    }
  

With rc = clCkptCheckpointOpen we attempt to open the specified checkpoint. When checkpoint_initialize is called the checkpoint may or may not exist. We attempt to open the checkpoint for READ/WRITE access.

Next we check if we created the checkpoint and then we need to create the section with a call to clCkptSectionCreate. We pass the checkpoint handle obtained from clCkptCheckpointOpen, the section attributes declared earlier, and the address of the initial value along with the size in bytes of the initial value.

We convert the initial value to network byte order by the code seq_no = htonl(seq), before passing it to clCkptSectionCreate.

If we do not create the section, then we read the current value in the checkpoint into our global seq variable.

Note that whenever we return an error return code from the function that we have either not opened the checkpoint/initialized the checkpoint service, or we have closed the checkpoint and finalized the checkpoint service with calls to clCkptCheckpointClose and clCkptFinalize.

    static ClRcT 
    checkpoint_finalize(void)
    {
        SaAisErrorT rc;

        rc = saCkptCheckpointClose(ckpt_handle);
        if (rc != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: failed: [0x%x] to close checkpoint handle 0x%llx",
                        appname, rc, ckpt_handle);
        }
        rc = saCkptFinalize(ckpt_svc_handle);
        if (rc != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"%s: failed: [0x%x] to finalize checkpoint",
                    appname, rc);
        }
        return CL_OK;

    }
  

The above code snippet presents checkpoint_finalize. It's quite simple. First it closes the checkpoint handle with a call to clCkptCheckpointClose. Next it finalizes the checkpoint library with a call to clCkptFinalize.

    static ClRcT
    checkpoint_write_seq(ClUint32T seq)
    {
        SaAisErrorT rc = SA_AIS_OK;
        ClUint32T seq_no;

        /* Putting data in network byte order */
        seq_no = htonl(seq);

        /* Write checkpoint */
        retry:
        rc = saCkptSectionOverwrite(ckpt_handle,
                                &ckpt_sid,
                                &seq_no,
                                sizeof(ClUint32T));
        if (rc != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"Failed [0x%x] to write to section", rc);
            if(rc == SA_AIS_ERR_NOT_EXIST)
                rc = checkpoint_replica_activate();
            if(rc == CL_OK) goto retry;
        }
        else
        {
            /*
            * Synchronize the checkpoint to all the replicas.
            */
            rc = saCkptCheckpointSynchronize(ckpt_handle, SA_TIME_END );
            if (rc != SA_AIS_OK)
            {
                clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"Failed [0x%x] to synchronize the checkpoint", rc);
            }
        }

        return CL_OK;
     }
  

With checkpoint_write_seq we first convert the sequence number passed into network byte order. Then we pass it to clCKptSectionOverwrite which writes it to the checkpoint section created in checkpoint_initialize.

    static ClRcT
    checkpoint_read_seq(ClUint32T *seq)
    {
        ClRcT rc = CL_OK;
        ClUint32T err_idx; /* Error index in ioVector */
        ClUint32T seq_no = 0xffffffff;
        SaCkptIOVectorElementT iov = {
            .sectionId  = ckpt_sid,
            .dataBuffer = (ClPtrT)&seq_no,
            .dataSize   = sizeof(ClUint32T),
            .dataOffset = (ClOffsetT)0,
            .readSize   = sizeof(ClUint32T)
        };

        rc = saCkptCheckpointRead(ckpt_handle, &iov, 1, &err_idx);
        if (rc != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
           clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,"Error: [0x%x] from checkpoint read, err_idx = %u",
                    rc, err_idx);
        }

        /* FIXME: How to process this err_idx? */
        *seq = ntohl(seq_no);

        return CL_OK;

    }

  

With checkpoint_read_seq we initialize seq_no to all ones just so it will be more obvious if the clCkptCheckpointRead call fails and the value of seq_no doesn't get overwritten. Then, we set up the iov variable. We set the sectionID field to ckpt_sid which is the id of the section created in checkpoint_initialize. The dataBuffer gets set to the address of the seq_no variable which is where we want the checkpoint data loaded. The dataSize field is set to the the size of the seq_no variable. DataOfset is set to zero since the sequence number is the only thing stored in the section, so it resides at the front of the section. readSize is set to the size of the sequence number variable.

Within checkpoint_read_seq we pass the iovector to clCkptCheckpointRead along with the ckpt_handle, the constant 1, and the address of the err_idx variable. The constant 1 is the number of elements in the array of ClCkptIOVectorElementT structs that we're passing. That is, we're passing the address of a single ClCkptIOVectorElementT struct. The err_idx will hold the index in that array where clCkptCheckpointRead found an error. That is, if there is going to be an error, it will be at index 0 since we're only passing on entry in the iovector.

    static ClRcT
    checkpoint_replica_activate(void)
    {
        SaAisErrorT rc = SA_AIS_OK;

        if ((rc = saCkptActiveReplicaSet(ckpt_handle)) != SA_AIS_OK)
        {
            clprintf(CL_LOG_SEV_ERROR,
                    "checkpoint_replica_activate failed [0x%x] in ActiveReplicaSet",
                    rc);
        }
        else rc = CL_OK;

        return rc;
    }
  

csa203

csa203 demonstrates the usage of SA Forum's Checkpointing service. This sample application does not deviate functionally from csa103. The code differences are due to using SA Forum data types (structures) and APIs , as presented in the following two tables. (Note we have not repeated data types and APIs covered previously.)

How to Run csa103 and What to Observe

This sample application can run on all Runtime Hardware Setups. The following, lists which node csa103compI* runs on.

• Runtime Hardware Setup 1.1 and 2.1
  csa103compI0 and csa103compI1 will run upon the single node.
• Runtime Hardware Setup 1.2 and 2.2
  csa103compI0 runs on PayloadNodeI0 and csa103compI1 runs on PayloadNodeI1
• Runtime Hardware Setup 1.3 and 2.3
  csa103compI2 and csa103compI3 run on SCNodeI0 and SCNodeI1 respectively. csa103compI0 and csa103compI1 run on PayloadNodeI0 and PayloadNodeI1 respectively.
  
  In the four node set up SCNodeI0 and SCNodeI1 output data via /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI2 and /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI3 respectively. Therefore in this case follow the below instructions replacing csa103CompI0 and csa103compI1 with csa103compI2 and csa103compI3 respectively.

We run csa103 very much the same way we run any of the rest of the sample applications: with the SAFplus Platform Console.

1. First, on the active System Controller move it to state LockAssignment with (Unlock csa203SGI0 instead of csa103SGI0 to run csa203)

   cli[Test]-> setc 1
   cli[Test:SCNodeI0]-> setc cpm
   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM]-> amsLockAssignment sg csa103SGI0
   

   The following output is given when you run tail -f on the csa103 log files. For example:

   # tail -f /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI0.log
   

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI0Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00030 : INFO) Component [csa103CompI0] : PID [15238]. Initializing Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00031 : INFO) IOC Address  : 0x1 Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00032 : INFO) IOC Port  : 0x81 Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00033 : INFO) csa103: Instantiated as component instance csa103CompI0. Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00034 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00035 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00036 : INFO) csa103CompI0: checkpoint_initialize Mon Jul 14 00:01:10 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00043 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Checkpoint service initialized (handle=0x1) Mon Jul 14 00:01:10 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00045 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Checkpoint opened (handle=0x2)

   # tail -f /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1.log
   

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00030 : INFO) Component [csa103CompI1] : PID [15234]. Initializing Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00031 : INFO) IOC Address  : 0x1 Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00032 : INFO) IOC Port  : 0x80 Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00033 : INFO) csa103: Instantiated as component instance csa103CompI1. Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00034 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00035 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00036 : INFO) csa103CompI1: checkpoint_initialize Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00043 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Checkpoint service initialized (handle=0x1) Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00045 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Checkpoint opened (handle=0x2) Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00053 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Section created

2. Then, unlock the application by running

   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM]-> amsUnlock sg csa103SGI0
   

   In the application log files, you should see

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI0Log.latest
   Mon Jul 14 00:09:08 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00058 : INFO) Standby state requested from state 0

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:09:08 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00064 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Active state requested from state 0 Mon Jul 14 00:09:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00065 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=0) Mon Jul 14 00:09:10 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00066 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=1) Mon Jul 14 00:09:11 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00067 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=2) Mon Jul 14 00:09:12 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00068 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=3) Mon Jul 14 00:09:13 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00069 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=4)

3. Next, find the active csa103 process, the one that's printing the Hello World lines and kill it. To find the process ID issue the following command from a bash shell.

    # ps -eaf | grep csa103
   

   This should produce an output that looks similar to the following.

   root     17830 15663  0 14:21 ?        00:00:00 csa103Comp -p
   root     17839 15663  0 14:21 ?        00:00:00 csa103Comp -p
   root     18558 16145  0 14:32 pts/4    00:00:00 grep csa103
   

   Notice the two entries that end with csa103Comp -p. These are our two component processes. The first one is usually the active process. This is the one that we will kill. In this case the process ID is 17830. So to kill the active component you issue the command:

   # kill -9 17830
   

   If this step does not result in the active component being killed then it is likely that the standby component was killed. In this case simply try killing the other process.

   After killing the active component you should see lines in the log files like the following:

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:16:43 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00515 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=452) Mon Jul 14 00:16:44 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00516 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=453) Mon Jul 14 00:16:45 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00517 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=454) Mon Jul 14 00:16:46 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00518 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=455)

   /var/log/csa103CompI0Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:16:48 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00065 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Active state requested from state 2 Mon Jul 14 00:16:48 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00066 : INFO) csa103CompI0 reading checkpoint Mon Jul 14 00:16:48 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00067 : INFO) csa103CompI0 read checkpoint: seq = 456 Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00068 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Hello World! (seq=456) Mon Jul 14 00:16:50 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00069 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Hello World! (seq=457) Mon Jul 14 00:16:51 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00070 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Hello World! (seq=458)

   Where we can see CompI1 printing 455 and then dieing, where upon CompI0 gets the notice to take over processing, reads the checkpoint and then takes over with seq=456 and so on.

   Then, in the CompI1 log file we see:

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00044 : INFO) csa103: Instantiated as component instance csa103CompI1. Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00045 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00046 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00047 : INFO) csa103CompI1: checkpoint_initialize Mon Jul 14 00:16:50 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00054 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Checkpoint service initialized (handle=0x1) Mon Jul 14 00:16:50 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00056 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Checkpoint opened (handle=0x2)

   That is the component that had been killed being restarted.

   CompI0 is moving along just fine, and we see CompI1 come back up. If we then kill CompI0 we see:

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:29:44 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00065 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Active state requested from state 2 Mon Jul 14 00:29:44 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00066 : INFO) csa103CompI1 reading checkpoint Mon Jul 14 00:29:44 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00067 : INFO) csa103CompI1 read checkpoint: seq = 1225 Mon Jul 14 00:29:45 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00068 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=1225) Mon Jul 14 00:29:46 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00069 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=1226)

   Where we can see the CompI0 process die, and CompI1 process read the sequence number from the checkpoint and then take over from where CompI0 left off.

4. To stop csa103 use the following SAFplus Platform Console command.

   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM]-> amsLockAssignment sg csa103SGI0
   

5. Now change the state of csa103SGI0 to LockInstantiation and close the SAFplus Platform Console.

   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM]-> amsLockInstantiation sg csa103SGI0
   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM] -> end
   cli[Test:SCNodeI0] -> end
   cli[Test] -> bye
   

csa203

csa203 demonstrates the usage of SA Forum's Checkpointing service. This sample application does not deviate functionally from csa103. The code differences are due to using SA Forum data types (structures) and APIs , as presented in the following two tables. (Note we have not repeated data types and APIs covered previously.)

How to Run csa103 and What to Observe

This sample application can run on all Runtime Hardware Setups. The following, lists which node csa103compI* runs on.

• Runtime Hardware Setup 1.1 and 2.1
  csa103compI0 and csa103compI1 will run upon the single node.
• Runtime Hardware Setup 1.2 and 2.2
  csa103compI0 runs on PayloadNodeI0 and csa103compI1 runs on PayloadNodeI1
• Runtime Hardware Setup 1.3 and 2.3
  csa103compI2 and csa103compI3 run on SCNodeI0 and SCNodeI1 respectively. csa103compI0 and csa103compI1 run on PayloadNodeI0 and PayloadNodeI1 respectively.
  
  In the four node set up SCNodeI0 and SCNodeI1 output data via /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI2 and /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI3 respectively. Therefore in this case follow the below instructions replacing csa103CompI0 and csa103compI1 with csa103compI2 and csa103compI3 respectively.

We run csa103 very much the same way we run any of the rest of the sample applications: with the SAFplus Platform Console.

1. First, on the active System Controller move it to state LockAssignment with (Unlock csa203SGI0 instead of csa103SGI0 to run csa203)

   cli[Test]-> setc 1
   cli[Test:SCNodeI0]-> setc cpm
   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM]-> amsLockAssignment sg csa103SGI0
   

   The following output is given when you run tail -f on the csa103 log files. For example:

   # tail -f /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI0.log
   

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI0Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00030 : INFO) Component [csa103CompI0] : PID [15238]. Initializing Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00031 : INFO) IOC Address  : 0x1 Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00032 : INFO) IOC Port  : 0x81 Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00033 : INFO) csa103: Instantiated as component instance csa103CompI0. Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00034 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00035 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00036 : INFO) csa103CompI0: checkpoint_initialize Mon Jul 14 00:01:10 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00043 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Checkpoint service initialized (handle=0x1) Mon Jul 14 00:01:10 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00045 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Checkpoint opened (handle=0x2)

   # tail -f /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1.log
   

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00030 : INFO) Component [csa103CompI1] : PID [15234]. Initializing Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00031 : INFO) IOC Address  : 0x1 Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00032 : INFO) IOC Port  : 0x80 Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00033 : INFO) csa103: Instantiated as component instance csa103CompI1. Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00034 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00035 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00036 : INFO) csa103CompI1: checkpoint_initialize Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00043 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Checkpoint service initialized (handle=0x1) Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00045 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Checkpoint opened (handle=0x2) Mon Jul 14 00:01:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00053 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Section created

2. Then, unlock the application by running

   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM]-> amsUnlock sg csa103SGI0
   

   In the application log files, you should see

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI0Log.latest
   Mon Jul 14 00:09:08 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00058 : INFO) Standby state requested from state 0

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:09:08 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00064 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Active state requested from state 0 Mon Jul 14 00:09:09 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00065 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=0) Mon Jul 14 00:09:10 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00066 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=1) Mon Jul 14 00:09:11 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00067 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=2) Mon Jul 14 00:09:12 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00068 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=3) Mon Jul 14 00:09:13 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00069 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=4)

3. Next, find the active csa103 process, the one that's printing the Hello World lines and kill it. To find the process ID issue the following command from a bash shell.

    # ps -eaf | grep csa103
   

   This should produce an output that looks similar to the following.

   root     17830 15663  0 14:21 ?        00:00:00 csa103Comp -p
   root     17839 15663  0 14:21 ?        00:00:00 csa103Comp -p
   root     18558 16145  0 14:32 pts/4    00:00:00 grep csa103
   

   Notice the two entries that end with csa103Comp -p. These are our two component processes. The first one is usually the active process. This is the one that we will kill. In this case the process ID is 17830. So to kill the active component you issue the command:

   # kill -9 17830
   

   If this step does not result in the active component being killed then it is likely that the standby component was killed. In this case simply try killing the other process.

   After killing the active component you should see lines in the log files like the following:

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:16:43 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00515 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=452) Mon Jul 14 00:16:44 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00516 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=453) Mon Jul 14 00:16:45 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00517 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=454) Mon Jul 14 00:16:46 2008 (SCNodeI0.15234 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00518 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=455)

   /var/log/csa103CompI0Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:16:48 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00065 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Active state requested from state 2 Mon Jul 14 00:16:48 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00066 : INFO) csa103CompI0 reading checkpoint Mon Jul 14 00:16:48 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00067 : INFO) csa103CompI0 read checkpoint: seq = 456 Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00068 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Hello World! (seq=456) Mon Jul 14 00:16:50 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00069 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Hello World! (seq=457) Mon Jul 14 00:16:51 2008 (SCNodeI0.15238 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00070 : INFO) csa103CompI0: Hello World! (seq=458)

   Where we can see CompI1 printing 455 and then dieing, where upon CompI0 gets the notice to take over processing, reads the checkpoint and then takes over with seq=456 and so on.

   Then, in the CompI1 log file we see:

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00044 : INFO) csa103: Instantiated as component instance csa103CompI1. Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00045 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00046 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Waiting for CSI assignment... Mon Jul 14 00:16:49 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00047 : INFO) csa103CompI1: checkpoint_initialize Mon Jul 14 00:16:50 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00054 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Checkpoint service initialized (handle=0x1) Mon Jul 14 00:16:50 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00056 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Checkpoint opened (handle=0x2)

   That is the component that had been killed being restarted.

   CompI0 is moving along just fine, and we see CompI1 come back up. If we then kill CompI0 we see:

   /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest

   Mon Jul 14 00:29:44 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00065 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Active state requested from state 2 Mon Jul 14 00:29:44 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00066 : INFO) csa103CompI1 reading checkpoint Mon Jul 14 00:29:44 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00067 : INFO) csa103CompI1 read checkpoint: seq = 1225 Mon Jul 14 00:29:45 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00068 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=1225) Mon Jul 14 00:29:46 2008 (SCNodeI0.15553 : csa103CompEO.---.---.00069 : INFO) csa103CompI1: Hello World! (seq=1226)

   Where we can see the CompI0 process die, and CompI1 process read the sequence number from the checkpoint and then take over from where CompI0 left off.

4. To stop csa103 use the following SAFplus Platform Console command.

   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM]-> amsLockAssignment sg csa103SGI0
   

5. Now change the state of csa103SGI0 to LockInstantiation and close the SAFplus Platform Console.

   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM]-> amsLockInstantiation sg csa103SGI0
   cli[Test:SCNodeI0:CPM] -> end
   cli[Test:SCNodeI0] -> end
   cli[Test] -> bye
   

Additional Tests for Runtime Hardware Setup 1.3 and 2.3

Now repeat the experiment till the stage before we kill the active process and follow these steps.

Step A

1. Stop SAFplus Platform on SCNodeI0 using /etc/init.d/asp stop. Observer the logs /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI3Log.latest on SCNodeI1. This will become active and start printing the hello world logs as above. Note in this case active System Controller SCNode1 is still aware of PayloadNodeI0 and PayloadNodeI1.
2. Start looking at the logs for /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI0Log.latest in PayloadNodeI0. This will print the standby logs as above.
3. Stop SAFplus Platform on PayloadNodeI0 and start observing the logs on PayloadNodeI1 in /root/asp/var/log/csa103CompI1Log.latest for standby. In this case, you can see, via the active System Controller logs that PayloadNodeI0 is not active whilst PayloadNodeI1 is.

Step B For Hardware Setup 1.3 only

1. Repeat A with the slight exception that the blade running SCNodeI0 is yanked out(/etc/init.d/asp zap) instead of gracefully shutting down SAFplus Platform in step 1.

Summary and References

We've seen :

• how to use Clovis' checkpoint service to save some program state and recover that state from a separate process
• how to initialize the client checkpoint library
• how to create and open checkpoints
• how to create and use sections in an opened checkpoint

Further information can be found within the following: OpenClovis API Reference Guide.